Optional upgrades
-
2 tbsp chopped fresh dill or parsley
-
3 slices cooked bacon, crumbled
-
1–2 tbsp capers for a briny twist
Equipment
-
Large pot
-
Colander
-
Mixing bowl
-
Sharp knife + cutting board
-
Spoon/spatula
How to Make the Potato Salad Everyone Loves
Step 1: Cook the potatoes the right way
Wash the potatoes and cut into bite-size chunks (about 1-inch pieces). Try to keep them evenly sized so they cook at the same rate.
Place potatoes in a large pot and cover with cold water by 1–2 inches. Add 1 tablespoon salt to the water.
Bring to a boil, then reduce to a steady simmer. Cook 10–12 minutes, or until a fork slides in easily but the potato doesn’t crumble apart.
Key tip: Start in cold water so the potatoes cook evenly from the inside out.
Drain well and let the potatoes sit in the colander for 3–5 minutes to release steam (this prevents watery potato salad).
Step 2: Season the potatoes while warm (the secret move)
Transfer warm potatoes to a large bowl. While they’re still warm, drizzle with:
-
vinegar
-
pickle juice
Gently toss. This step seasons the potatoes inside, not just on the surface. It’s the difference between “pretty good” and “everyone asks for the recipe.”
Let potatoes cool 10–15 minutes before adding the mayo-based dressing.
Step 3: Make the creamy-tangy dressing
In a bowl, whisk together:
-
mayonnaise
-
sour cream or Greek yogurt
-
Dijon mustard
-
yellow mustard (optional)
-
sugar (if using)
-
salt, pepper, paprika
Taste. You want it creamy, slightly tangy, and well-seasoned. Remember: potatoes mute seasoning, so the dressing should taste a little stronger than you think it needs to.
Step 4: Add mix-ins
Fold into the potatoes:
-
chopped eggs
-
celery
-
red onion
-
pickles
-
herbs (if using)
Step 5: Dress the salad gently
Add the dressing and fold until everything is coated. Don’t overmix—this keeps the potatoes chunky instead of mashed.
If it looks dry, add 1–2 more tablespoons mayo. If it looks too thick, add a teaspoon of pickle juice or a splash of milk.
Step 6: Chill for best flavor
Cover and refrigerate at least 1–2 hours, ideally 4 hours, before serving. The flavors deepen and the texture becomes perfectly scoopable.
Before serving, taste again and adjust salt/pepper. Garnish with paprika and herbs.
The “Modern Twist” (What Makes It Different)
This isn’t potato salad reinvented—it’s potato salad improved:
-
Greek yogurt or sour cream adds a clean tang and keeps it from feeling greasy.
-
Dijon mustard adds complexity without overpowering.
-
Pickle juice + vinegar on warm potatoes seasons them from the inside.
-
Fine dice on celery and onion gives crunch in every bite without big raw chunks.
It still tastes like classic potato salad—just brighter, better balanced, and more craveable.
Best Potatoes for Potato Salad
-
Yukon Gold: creamy, buttery, holds shape well (best overall)
-
Red potatoes: firmer, great if you like chunky salad
-
Russet: soft and fluffy, but can fall apart (use gently)
If you only have russets, cook carefully and mix gently. They’ll taste great but the salad will be a bit more “rustic and creamy.”
Variations Everyone Will Love
Southern-style
Add:
-
1 tsp celery seed
-
1 tbsp sweet relish
-
more yellow mustard
Optional: a pinch of cayenne
German-inspired
Swap dressing:
-
use a warm vinegar dressing with bacon and onions (no mayo)
Loaded baked potato salad
Add:
-
cheddar cheese
-
bacon
-
green onions
-
a bit more sour cream
Lighter version
-
Use half mayo, half Greek yogurt
-
Add extra herbs and lemon juice for brightness
What to Serve With Potato Salad
-
Burgers, hot dogs, grilled chicken, BBQ ribs
-
Fried chicken or pulled pork
-
Sandwiches and wraps
-
Picnic spreads (with coleslaw, baked beans, corn on the cob)
This potato salad is especially good with smoky grilled foods because the tang cuts through rich flavors.
Storage and Food Safety
-
Store covered in the fridge for up to 4 days.
-
Don’t leave it out longer than 2 hours (1 hour in hot weather).
-
If making ahead for a party, keep it chilled until serving.
Pro storage tip: Save 2 tablespoons of dressing and stir it in the next day to refresh creaminess.
Troubleshooting
“My potato salad is watery.”
-
Potatoes weren’t drained long enough
-
Mixed while potatoes were too hot (mayo thins)
Fix: Chill, then stir in a spoonful of mayo or a little mashed potato to thicken.
“It tastes bland.”
Potatoes need more seasoning than you think. Add:
-
salt
-
a splash more pickle juice or vinegar
-
extra mustard
Taste again after chilling.
“It turned gummy.”
Overmixed or cut potatoes too small. Mix gently and keep chunks around 1 inch.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I make potato salad the day before?
Yes—actually it’s best that way. Make it the day before, chill overnight, and refresh with a spoonful of mayo if needed.
Do I have to peel the potatoes?
No. Yukon Gold skins are thin and tender. Peeling is optional.
Can I use sweet pickles instead of dill?
Absolutely. If using sweet pickles or relish, reduce or skip the sugar.
Can I add celery salt or celery seed?
Yes—start with ¼ tsp, taste, and adjust.
