If you go the red route, a satin or semi‑gloss finish tends to look more intentional and furniture‑grade than flat paint. Using a high‑quality enamel or cabinet paint would also help it wear better over time.
A compromise you both might like
If you and your husband are split, consider these middle‑ground options instead of full coverage:
-
Two‑tone finish: Keep the outer frame in wood and paint only the drawer fronts red (or vice versa). That keeps some natural character while giving you the pop of color you want.
-
Accent color inside: Leave the outside wood and paint the drawer interiors or side panels red. You get a fun surprise every time you open it, without changing how it looks from across the room.
-
Stain rather than paint: A warm cherry, mahogany, or even subtle reddish stain can shift the color toward red but still let the grain show, which might satisfy both “keep the wood” and “add red” camps.
Trying a quick digital mock‑up (snap a photo and overlay color on a phone or tablet) can help you both see which option feels right before committing.
Practical tips if you decide to paint
If you ultimately win the debate and go red, treat it like a cabinet‑grade project so it still feels upscale:
-
Lightly sand to de‑gloss, use a good bonding primer, then follow with 2–3 thin coats of durable furniture or cabinet enamel in your chosen red.
-
Consider brushed brass, black, or even crystal knobs to dress it up and tie the red into other elements in the room.
-
Keep wall color and surrounding pieces calmer so the dresser doesn’t have to fight for attention.
Done carefully, either choice—wood or red—can look fantastic. If the room already has plenty of personality, staying with the original finish is safer; if the space feels flat and you love bold, quirky pieces, a thoughtful red could turn it into the star of the house.
